Betting a Billion Dollars Against a Bubble
On Monday, Constellation Brands announced it was acquiring San Diego’s Ballast Point Brewing Co. Big whoop, right? It seems like one of the big beer companies buys a craft brewery about every other week. But here’s the actual news within the story: Constellation—which owns the U.S. rights to Corona and Modelo and is the country’s largest wine company—paid a cool billion dollars for the right to sell Sculpin IPA. A craft brewery buyout is barely worth noting, but a craft brewery that last year only sold 113,000 barrels going for a billion dollars? That’s news.
Let’s unpack some numbers and see if we can figure out why. It’s not because the four Ballast facilities around San Diego are worth a billion dollars; far from it. This summer, when Lagunitas sold a 50 percent stake to Heineken, reports suggested the brewery was also valued at a billion dollars. But Lagunitas has two breweries, with a third on the way, which will push capacity toward 2 million barrels a year. Ballast Point has a very strong brand and one of the most beloved IPAs in the country—but it brewed less than a fifth as much beer as Lagunitas.
Rather, Constellation is looking at Ballast Point’s future value. When you consider what a company is worth, you look at all its hard assets, its liabilities, its annual earnings, and its future potential. In the case of Constellation, they’re betting that the market shift, from mass market lagers to fuller-flavor lagers and ales (what we used to call “craft beer”), is only getting started.
When the news broke, I pinged Oregon State University professor Patrick Emerson (and my Beervana podcast co-host) about the news. He agreed that Constellation is looking to the future. “This sum is eye popping, but I think you hit the nail on the head. They need an entry into craft beer and they are making a big bet that this brand can be built up. My reading of this move by Constellation is that this is a play to build Ballast Point into a major national brand.”
Many observers believe this is further evidence of a bubble in the “craft” segment—the outrageous prices paid for breweries remind them of mortgages in 2007. Of course, that’s always possible. If the market flatlines tomorrow, Constellation will lose big on the deal. But consider: since 1990 or so, the overall beer market in the United States has remained a pretty steady 200 million barrels. (Per-capita beer consumption has declined, but the population keeps growing.) In 1990, pretty close to 100 percent of the market was mass market lagers. By 2015, the 200 million barrels of mass market lager had shrunk to about 175, and that drop-off curve gets steeper each year. They are currently hemorrhaging two or three million barrels a year, and if trends continue, that number will grow faster.
If you like the work I do, consider supporting Beervana. You can be a supporter by setting up a recurring donation, or make a one-time donation. If you're inspired, donate here. Thanks so much!
Big beer companies are well aware of these trends, and they’re asking themselves the same question: How much of the market 10 years from now will still be mass market lagers? The moves breweries make now reflects their answer to that question. When I speak to beer fans around the country and see comments on social media, they usually assume there’s a fairly low cap on the amount craft beer can grow. The big beer companies aren’t thinking of it that way. They assume mass market lagers are going to continue to decline in the future, and it’s why they have to figure out a way to get in on the craft pie.
A couple years ago, I got to sit down with Pat McGauley, whose title is Vice President of Innovation and New Products for Anheuser-Busch InBev (unnecessarily long in the convention of corporate titles). He acknowledged that the world was changing, and irrevocably. “We understand the dynamics in the palate shifts, the number of beers that are in people’s drink sets. People are drinking craft beers for specific occasions—they still may have light, regular beers in their set—but they’re drinking IPAs and pale ales. You can’t stick your head in the sand and say ‘I hope this goes away.’” In the years since he told me that, AB InBev has added four regional craft breweries to its portfolio. And just to illustrate how quickly the thinking has changed, when ABI made its first craft acquisition in 2011—of Chicago’s Goose Island—it paid a paltry $39 million. With an “m.”
You may think this is a bubble, and you may be right. What this billion-dollar announcement today tells us is that big beer companies don’t agree. They look at that 200 million barrel U.S. beer market and see a lot more craft in its future—and they’re willing to pay a king’s ransom to make sure they have a brand in the game.
December 3, 2019
[Epilogue] Tiny Chicago Brewery Purchases Brand Formerly Valued at $1 Billion
A two-year-old Chicago concern that touts “great craft beer and golf simulators,” today announced it had purchased Ballast Point. Named Kings and Convicts in honor of its Australian and English founders, the company has 334 Instagram followers. Upon hearing the news, every living being on the planet responded: “Who?”
The website immediately crashed, so little is known about the company. The press release offers these tidbits:
Kings & Convicts is a privately held company headquartered in Highwood, IL, in the North Shore of Chicago. Conceived by an Englishman and an Aussie, Kings & Convicts started brewing for the public in 2017 and was built on the freedom of anti-authority and the spirit of fellowship. They brew ales and lagers inspired by the tales of convicts, royalty and the undercurrent of American gangsters. Every beer tells a story. Kings & Convicts’ beer is available on draft and in cans at its taproom and in bars and restaurants across Chicagoland and southern Wisconsin.
Back in 2015, Ballast Point was the hottest brewery in the US, selling six-packs of Grapefruit Sculpin for $15 and leading a trend that would last well into 2016. Constellation Brands, then principally an importer, swooped in and purchased the California juggernaut for a cool $1 billion. It seemed a tad high at the time, but those were heady days.
Things have changed. The zeitgeist in beer shifted from clarion, bitter (and citrus-flavored) San Diego IPAs to murky, sweet New England hazies. Constellation recognized its error and started buying smaller breweries instead (“At the time we acquired Ballast Point, we thought there would be more national brands that broke out.”) Earlier this year, Constellation had to close locations and spiked further expansion—and was apparently looking for suitors in the meantime. Or CEO Bill Newlands drunkenly lost Ballast in a poker game. Or something.
Update. This San Diego Union-Tribune piece has some additional details:
Kings and Convicts makes 600 barrels a year. That’s a six with two zeros, not four or five.
Kings and Convicts employs nine people.
The new company will be headquartered in San Diego.
Ballast has lost over half its volume, from a high of 431,000 bbls to something like 200k this year.
Brendan Watters, co-owner, was meeting with Constellation executives in July. Actual conversation: “Is it for sale?” he asked, half-joking. The response: “Would you like to buy it?”